A hairstylist slipped at a golf course and claimed compensation of 2.55 million. Despite the injury, they completed all 18 holes and ultimately received a compensation of 110,000.
讀後心得
A man named 石男 slipped on a puddle in the lobby of a golf course and demanded a compensation of over 2.55 million yuan. However, less than a month later, he returned to the golf course to play, and ultimately only received a compensation of over 110,000 yuan. The incident occurred in November 2023, where 石男 sustained injuries from the fall and submitted various medical expense claims. After an investigation, the Tainan District Court found that the golf course was at fault, but since 石男 continued to play frequently after his injury, it affected the compensation amount. In the end, it was determined that both parties were equally responsible, and the golf course was required to compensate 石男 with over 110,000 yuan.
A male hairdresser went to a golf course in Tainan to play golf in November 2023, and accidentally slipped on standing water in the lobby, therefore seeking compensation from the course for over 2.55 million yuan. Although he claimed to have suffered multiple injuries to his head and neck due to the incident and stated that he needed three months of recuperation, shortly after the incident, he surprisingly played golf again just 21 days later and has since played a total of 26 times. The judge ultimately ruled that this was inconsistent with medical advice, hence only ordered compensation of about 110,000 yuan.
The judgment mentioned that on November 20, 2023, the man named Shi went to the golf course, where the lobby was undergoing floor cleaning. When he passed by at 9:46 AM, he slipped due to the wet floor, causing multiple injuries, and subsequently filed a claim for medical expenses. The golf course claimed in its defense that there were cleaning staff working that day and asserted that Shi's slip was unrelated to the course.
After deliberation, the judge found that the golf course had not set up warning tape to prevent incidents, indicating negligence on its part. Although the course attempted to point out that the diagnosis certificate mentioned "limited activity," the judge still believed that Shi's actions exceeded the recommendations of the medical advice.
Ultimately, the judge determined that the duration of Shi's injury impact was 21 days, and ordered the golf course to pay 111,641 yuan, with both parties bearing 50% of the accident's responsibility. Additionally, the judgment can be appealed.